Controversial texts in the Old Testament

This course examines controversial texts of the Hebrew Bible from the point of view of the contemporary Christian reader. The texts discussed often played - not only in the contemporary discourse, but throughout the history of the Old Testament hermeneutics - an important role in challenging the relevance and normativity of the Old Testament for modern theological thinking. The course reveals the history of the interpretation of these texts and seeks the hermeneutical key through which the texts can retain their legitimacy in the canon of the Christian church and beyond.

Competences

Specific competences

The student will become aware of the differences in the hermeneutical principles of the original authors of the Old Testament and the modern reader. He/she will be able to apply the hermeneutical considerations learned in the case studies to any problematic biblical text.

General competences

By confronting critical situations in the Old Testament, the student develops a nuanced attitude toward situations that differ from the ordinary. The course develops the student's critical thinking, discernment and reflection skills.

Course structure

  1. Introduction. Is the Old Testament a Christian text?

    This course is a general introduction to the Old Testament texts which, throughout the history of interpretation, have raised serious questions in Judaism, Christianity or in contemporary cultures building upon those, and have often become the subject of apologetic discourse. The presentation will outline the basic aspects, reasons and interpretative paradigms that have played a role in the hermeneutical process.

    Reading:

    • Csaba Balogh: Az Ószövetség (meghatározó) szerepe a református igehirdetésben, avagy: Kell-e nekünk az Ószövetség, s ha igen, mit kezdjünk vele?, 243-252 (10)
  2. It repented the LORD that he had made man on the earth (Gen 6:6) – Limits and possibilities of Old Testament theology

    Reading:

    • Csaba Balogh: Megbánó Isten - változó Isten. Az ószövetségi teológia korlátairól és lehetőségeiről, 9-31 (23)
    • Jenő Kiss: Isten megbánása, 5-11 (7)
    • Jeremias, Jörg: Die Reue Gottes. Aspekte alttestamentlicher Gottesvorstellung
    • Döhling, Jan-Dirk: Der bewegliche Gott. Eine Untersuchung des Motivs der Reue in der Hebräischen Bibel
    • Amit, Yairah: "The Glory of Israel Does Not Deceive or Change His Mind". On the Reliability of Narrator and Speakers in Biblical Narrative, 201-212 (12)
    • Angel, Hayyim: The Uncertainty Principle of Repentance in the Books of Jonah and Joel, 148-161 (14)
    • Brunners, Wilhelm: Wenn Gott seine Meinung ändert... Ungewohnte Rede von Gott, 18-21 (4)
    • Freedman, David Noel: When God Repents, 409-446 (38)
    • Fretheim, Terence E.: The Repentance of God. A Key to Evaluating Old Testament God-Talk, 47-70 (24)
  3. The LORD thy God is a jealous God (Deut 6:15) – Exclusivism and intolerance in the Old Testament

    Reading:

    • Csaba Balogh: Exkluzivizmus, intolerancia és az Ószövetség világa, 21-40 (20)
  4. I loved Jacob and I hated Esau (Mal 1:2-3) – Election and rejection

  5. O God, to whom vengeance belongs, show thyself (Zsolt 94:1) – The place of negative emotions in Israel's faith

    Reading:

    • Kató Szabolcs Ferencz: „Örül az igaz, mikor látja a bosszút, mikor lábát a gonoszok vérében mossa.” Az úgynevezett bosszúzsoltárok a נקם szemantikájának fényében, 605-642 (38)
    • Jeremias, Jörg: JHWH – ein Gott der „Rache“?, 89-104 (16)
    • Graupner, Axel: Vergeltung oder Schadensersatz? Erwägungen zur regulativen Idee alttestamentlichen Rechts am Beispiel des ius talionis und der mehrfachen Ersatzleistung im Bundesbuch, 459-477 (19)
    • Peels, Hendrik George Laurens: The vengeance of God. The Meaning of the Root NQM and the Function of the NQM-Texts in the Context of Divine Revelation in the Old Testament
    • Althann, Robert: The Psalms of Vengeance against Their Ancient Near Eastern Background, 1-11 (11)
    • Zenger, Erich: Ein Gott der Rache?
    • Zenger, Erich: Rache, 11-12 (2)
  6. I will visit the iniquity of the fathers upon the children (Ex 20:5) – The problem of collective responsibility in the Old Testament

    Reading:

    • Schmid, Konrad: Kollektivschuld? Der Gedanke übergreifender Schuldzusammenhänge im Alten Testament und im Alten Orient, 193-222 (30)
    • Mol, Jurrien: Collective and Individual Responsibility. A Description of Corporate Personality in Ezekiel 18 and 20
    • Robinson, Henry Wheeler: Corporate personality in ancient Israel
  7. Did you not pour me out like milk and curdle me like cheese? (Job 10:10) – The unknown faces of Old Testament anthropology

    Reading:

    • Csaba Balogh: Teremtés és születés. A Zsoltárok 139:13-16 antropológiai kérdései, 9-36 (28)
    • Csaba Balogh: Schöpfung und Geburt. Anthropologische Begrifflichkeit in Psalm 139,13-16, 147-176 (30)
    • Csaba Balogh: Noțiuni la antropologia Psalmului 139:13, 19-30 (12)
  8. The LORD encountered him and sought to kill him (Ex 4,24) - Is the God of the Old Testament dangerous?

    Reading:

    • Willis, John T.: Yahweh and Moses in Conflict. The Role of Exodus 4:24–26 in the Book of Exodus
    • Csaba Balogh: Miért akarta megölni Isten Mózest? A veszélyes Isten képzete az Exodus 4,24–26-ban
  9. Spare no one, but kill alike men and women(1Sam 15:3) - Holy war?

    Reading:

    • Copan, Paul: Is God a Moral Monster? Making Sense of the Old Testament God, 158-197 (40)
  10. Take your favored one, and offer him as a burnt offering (Gen 22:2) - Unrealistic ethical standards?

    Reading:

    • Copan, Paul: Is God a Moral Monster? Making Sense of the Old Testament God, 42-53 (12)
  11. Vanity of vanities! (Préd 1:2) - Philosophy of life from the margins of the Old Testament

  12. He cursed them in the name of the LORD (2 Kgs 2:24) – Holiness and worldview in the Old Testament

    Reading:

    • Parker, Julie Faith: Valuable and Vulnerable: Children in the Hebrew Bible, Especially the Elisha Cycle, 91-101 (11)
  13. It is a fearful thing to fall into the hands of the living God (Heb 10:31) - The other face of the New Testament

    Reading:

    • Seibert, Eric A.: Disturbing Divine Behavior: Troubling Old Testament Images of God, 169-181 (13)
  14. Evaluation

Total estimated time

Classroom study

  • 2 hours/week (Course: 2 | Seminar: 0 | Practice: 0)
  • 28 hours/semester (Course: 28 | Seminar: 0 | Practice: 0)

Individual study

  • Time for studying course notes and bibliography: 40 hours/semester.
  • Time for further documentation in libraries, electronic platforms, or on the field: 20 hours/semester.
  • Time for preparing essays, papers, or documentation: 0 hours/semester.
  • Time for personal tutoring: 0 hours/semester.
  • Total individual study: 60 hours/semester.
  • Total estimated time: 88 hours/semester.

Examination

Az írásbeli vizsga a kurzus keretében tárgyalt tematikákhoz kötődik. A cél a probléma-alapú megoldási készség felmérése. Az írásbeli vizsgán egy-egy problémás textus kapcsán kell a hallgatónak arra reflektálnia, hogy az adott bibliográfia ismeretében hogyan értelmezi a megjelölt bibliai perikópát vagy tematikát.